top of page

Fight for Your Italian Heritage: Appealing a Rejected Italian Citizenship Application

Don’t let rejection stop you from pursuing Italian citizenship. In this guide we explain the nuance to a successful appeal, including next steps after receiving a rejection and our expert tips to overcome your roadblock.



Introduction:

From genealogical research to waiting in the document backlog, obtaining Italian citizenship can take years. Having your case rejected after years of diligent research and patiently waiting your turn is devastating, but receiving a rejection isn’t the end of the road for your path to citizenship. Appealing a rejected case is a valid and worthwhile next step, especially in regards to ‘The Minor Issue’. Being informed about your options before your case is rejected is crucial as appeals need to be filed within 30 days.


Why Appeals Work: 


  • Missing DocumentationApplications can often be rejected due to incomplete documentation. An appeal allows you to submit any previously missing or overlooked documents to help strengthen your case.

  • Misinterpretation of Eligibility: Eligibility criteria can be complex. An appeal clarifies your situation and ensures your application aligns with the specific requirements for citizenship by descent or marriage.

  • Procedural Errors: An appeal highlights any procedural or administrative errors on the part of the authorities responsible for reviewing your case that might have impacted the initial decision.


Recognition of Italian citizenship is a legal process guided by laws. These laws are interpreted differently from court to court, consulate to consulate, and even judge to judge. An appeal gives you the opportunity to have your case examined from a different perspective.


Steps to a Successful Appeal:


Step 1: Understand the Reasons for Rejection

  • Obtain the Rejection Letter: An appeal cannot begin without first receiving the official rejection letter. It is vital that you request the official rejection if it was not sent to you. After rejection, you are entitled to request for your documents to be returned to you as you will need them for your appeal. In the letter, the specific reason(s) for rejection will be stated. From here you can start collecting missing documents, making necessary amendments, or looking for alternative lines.


Step 2: Gather Supporting Evidence

  • Solidify Your Case: Collect missing documents and make your case more clear cut by providing additional proof.

    • Ancestral birth certificates or marriage records not previously submitted.

    • Baptismal records, or other church records where birth or marriage certificates cannot be located.

    • Estate wills, or legal documentation proving paternity.

    • Declaratory judgements to claim that misspellings, nicknames, middle names, and AKAs are shown as one and the same person.

    • Census records

    • Naturalization records or CONEs for non-naturalized ancestors from USCIS and NARA

    • Proof of Italian language proficiency (if required).

To make an appeal successful, you must address any and all specific points raised in the rejection letter.


Step 3: Craft a Compelling Appeal Letter 

  • Structure and Tone: Maintain a clear, concise, and respectful tone throughout the letter.

  • Acknowledge the Rejection: Briefly acknowledge the initial decision but firmly state your belief it was incorrect.

  • Address Specific Issues: Meticulously address each point raised in the rejection letter. Explain any missing documentation you're now including or clarify any eligibility concerns.

  • Highlight Supporting Evidence: Mention any new documents you've attached and how they strengthen your case.


Step 4: Submitting Your Appeal 

  • Consult the Rejection Letter: The rejection letter typically outlines the specific channel for submitting an appeal (e.g., online portal, mail).

  • Deadlines: Appeals often have strict timeframes. Ensure you submit your appeal well within the designated deadline to avoid rejection on technical grounds.

  • Fees: There might be associated fees for submitting an appeal. Consult the relevant authority for details.


Step 5: Be Patient and Persistent 

  • Processing Times: The appeals process can take time. Remain patient and maintain open communication with the authorities handling your appeal.


While this guide provides a general framework, ICC engages with lawyers specializing in Italian citizenship can offer invaluable support. We can help you:

  • Craft a legally sound appeal letter.

  • Ensure your appeal adheres to all legal requirements.

  • Navigate any complexities that may arise during the process.


Remember, You're Not Alone

Rejection can feel isolating, but remember, you're not alone in this journey. Numerous resources exist to support your appeal.

While the internet offers various resources related to Italian citizenship applications, it's important to approach online information - as social platforms -  with a critical eye. Remember, every case is unique and requires a tailored approach. As a consultant, I often encounter misleading information online, which can create unnecessary confusion and delay the application and appeal processes.


Instead of relying on unverified sources, consider seeking guidance from reputable channels.


By focusing on reliable resources and professional guidance, you can navigate the appeals process with confidence and avoid the drama of potentially inaccurate online information.


The Takeaway:

Appealing a rejected Italian citizenship application requires determination. But remember, with careful planning, additional documentation, and a well-crafted appeal letter, you can increase your chances of success.

So, don't let a setback deter you. Embrace the challenge, gather your resources, and fight for your Italian citizenship.

bottom of page